The Six Levels of Treats (and how to determine their order)

http://thatdogdancingguy.com.au

One of the first things I learnt when I entered the crazy world of dog training was the different levels of training treats.

Being a typical Beagle meant that sometimes Luna would be happy with something, and then the next day wouldn’t bother even sitting for it. We quickly had to think up and organize her treats into levels so that if she was starting to lose focus we could mix it up for her. I never thought I would have the same issue with the Border Collie, Cynder, but she can also be a bit selective on what she will work for on a specific day.

Why Have a Treat Order?

Having different levels of treats also allows for that extra special reward for a really good job, for instance, a recall under complete distraction (3 or 4 dogs hanging around) or a trick that they’ve never learnt before. As you progress with learning a move or trick using a positive reward based training method the treats are slowly phased out until you are giving them random rewards mixed with praise at other times. This also helps to reduce the ‘will only work for food’ mantra.

How to Determine the Treat Order

You can determine the treat level system for your dog quite easily, have your dog on the lead and place two different types of treats on the floor just out of their reach. Let them see the treats for a good 10-15 seconds and then release them from the lead, make a note of the order in which they eat the treats. Try it again a few times and see if you get a consistent result. Make a list of treats that you can refer to if you ever find yourself at a loose end!

The List

From my experience there are six different levels of treats and the order in which they are preferenced can change from dog to dog, but this is a general guide and the level in which the Beagle and the Border Collie prefer their treats:

  • Kibble – Fairly low down on the list, and only really used if there is nothing else available, is their everyday kibble. They get it for free twice a day (though not without sitting patiently first) so why work for it? Plus it’s usually hard and requires chewing which can mean distraction!
  • Cat kibble – For similar reasons as dog kibble this one is pretty low down on the list (though they don’t get it everyday, actually usually not at all unless we just happen to have gotten some in a pack or something and can’t find someone to give it to). As cats are fussy eaters their kibble is generally coated with a layer of tallow which gives it that little extra appeal to dogs.
  • Extruded Treats – This category includes treats which are made from meat, but generally highly processed (and often full of salt). Treats like beef, chicken or liver treats can all be types of extruded treats. They are an ok occasional treat, but a bit fiddly as you would want to cut them up into smaller pieces first, even then a little bit of chewing required so your dog may lose focus.
  • Semi Moist Treats – A few different things fall into this category. Biscuits, chicken treat balls and the like. When we first started training Luna we used many treats that would have been classified as semi-moist which worked well at the time, but again, Luna would lose focus due to the chew factor, etc. When we made the switch to higher value treats it was such a shock the difference it made!
  • Moist Treats – This is probably the level of treats that we use most often and even have sublevels of treats in this level as well. The main treats which we give are: Devon(luncheon meat), Strassburg and Boiled Chicken. The first two in only small portions as they can be high in salt, but we find this stuff really works a treat! It can be cut into small enough pieces and is quick and easy to devour which means you can move straight on to something else.
  • Raw Meat – If you can handle it, raw meat is one of the best treats out there and can be used for really high rewards. I would only ever use this one for some really hardcore training and very sparingly so it always has that appeal. Things such as diced steak (cut into small enough pieces that can be eaten quick) or a chicken neck (which can be reserved for a really awesome recall or something as they take a little bit to chew) really work well in this category.

Luna at trainingThe best kind of treats are small (so that they don’t fill up quickly), don’t break apart easily (if you drop some treats, generally they will go scavenging for it and get distracted from the task at hand) and keep them motivated to continue training. It’s important to note that not all dogs will be treat motivated and instead prefer a game or praise. This is perfectly ok and means you can get creative with rewards. Also, remember to use a bridging word, such as ‘yes’, when training as this lets the dog know that a treat is coming and whatever they just did is the right thing! We will be talking more about this at a later stage!

Big thank you to Nicole Beasley of Planet K9 for her assistance with the treat levels!

 

What treat have you found work best for your dog? or if they aren’t treat focussed, how do you keep them motivated?

 

Bookmark the permalink.

18 Comments

  1. I really love this post. I will repost it !!! Congratulations!!! Woof. Nat

  2. Howdy Kevin, we’ve found with Stella she will work for any kind of food. She is a total food aholic. Will follow us off lead anywhere when she thinks we have food in our hands. Rory on the other hand, couldn’t care less about food. Hard to believe a big fella like him doesn’t really care too much about food. Thanks for the info. Hope you are all doing ok. No worries, and love, Carol (and Stella and Rory)

  3. Also remember not every dog will work for food, some will work for toys and motivational play 🙂

  4. Al treats are good for us. Any type any order. Have a fabulous Friday.
    Best wishes Molly

  5. An alternative to raw meat is boiled chicken which is easily chopped into small pieces. I like to carry a variety of treats to keep things lively. I do need to be careful with Dexter when I am working on difficult skills. High value treats will wind him up so much that he just throws everything he has at me without thinking. The primary treats I use with Dex are Charlie Bears as they are low calorie, but interesting enough to keep him working. Mango always needed hot dogs or cheese to keep him motivated.

    • I will have to try that with the chicken. Usually I boil and then shred but have issues with it going all over the place. Haha. What are Charlie Bears?

      Hmm. I find that a bit with Cynder sometimes as well. If she knows it’s a real high value treat she will go a bit nutty.

      Thanks for sharing! 🙂

  6. I always thought that in our dogs’ minds . . . every meal is a banquet!

  7. Great article. I’ve also found with the dogs I’ve worked with that treat preference varies greatly not only from breed to breed, but individual to individual. I had contact with a Shar Pei today who would not take treats at all. My mini foxie Ponyo would respond well, but only if I mixed it up (she was a sharp one) and as you mentioned, praise and play was an equal reward for her if not more rewarding. Ponyo had an Achilles heel though, and that was bacon. If you gave her even the tiniest sliver of bacon she would race around in absolute joy afterwards, we called it ‘bacon-fever’.
    I was wondering if you wouldn’t mind me linking this article on my Training and Behaviour resources page? You provide some really sound advice in your training articles.

  8. Pingback: “Oh, you give her treat rewards?” Positive Reinforcement Training Methods | "that dog dancing guy"

  9. Pingback: SavourLife: Saving lives one packet of dog treats at a time That Dog Dancing Guy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *